Editorial standards

These are the rules we follow for every article. If we break them, tell us.

How we check a clip

  • We watch the full clip, then find the full original: the whole interview, speech, programme or document.
  • Quotes come from the original footage, not from other outlets’ reports of it.
  • We go to primary sources first: official statistics, legislation, court records, original studies and documents.
  • Several outlets repeating the same source count as one source, not several.
  • We use other fact-checkers to find leads, then go to their sources ourselves.
  • Polls and surveys commissioned by campaigns, charities or companies are checked for method and question wording.

Our verdicts

Every factual claim we check gets one of these:

  • Verified: directly supported by reliable evidence.
  • Corroborated: supported by several genuinely independent sources.
  • Disputed: credible evidence or interpretations conflict.
  • Unsubstantiated: there isn’t enough evidence either way. This does not mean false.
  • Contradicted: reliable evidence conflicts with the claim.
  • Opinion: a view rather than a factual claim. We say so rather than giving it a verdict.

The Pull The Thread Triple Check

Every article ends with three checks, written about that specific story:

  1. Find it. We went back to the original: the full clip, the whole interview, the actual study or document.
  2. Follow it. We looked at who benefits if people believe it: money, votes, clicks or simply being proved right.
  3. Test it. We asked what else we’d expect to see if the claim were true, and looked for it.

Fairness

  • We set out the strongest version of the other side’s case, not the weakest.
  • We keep a running record of whose claims we check, and review it monthly so no side gets singled out.
  • We don’t pick clips just because they embarrass someone, and we don’t cover members of the public who went viral by accident.
  • Headlines must be supported by the article underneath them.

AI and human review

We use AI tools to help research and draft. Research, drafting and checking are separate steps, and claims are checked independently rather than by the same tool that wrote them. A human watches the clip, reviews the verdicts and approves every article before publication.

Using clips

Where possible we embed clips from their official source rather than re-uploading them, and we always credit the original.

See also our corrections policy.